India’s markets regulator, SEBI, is considering a series of adjustments to its derivative trading rules to manage risks from the rapid growth in options trading. Key points include:
1. Proposed Rule Changes:
– Higher Margins for Options Contracts: SEBI might increase margin requirements for trading options.
– Detailed Disclosures: Enhanced disclosure requirements for index and stock options contracts are being considered.
– Linking Options Trading to Cash Volumes: To limit open positions in less liquid stocks, options trading might be linked to underlying cash volumes.
– Flat Fees for Brokers: Exchanges could be asked to charge flat transaction fees to brokers, regardless of their turnover.
– Individual Stock Derivatives Rules: Tighter rules for derivatives linked to illiquid stocks may be implemented.
2. Reason for Changes:
– Retail Investor Participation: Retail investors have driven a significant increase in index and stock options trading.
– Explosive Growth: The notional value of index options traded in 2023-24 more than doubled to $907.09 trillion.
– Investor Protection: Concerns about future challenges for markets, investor sentiment, and household finances have been raised.
3. Regulatory and Government Concerns:
– Excessive Speculation and Manipulation: There is a need for appropriate risk disclosure and measures to prevent excessive speculation or manipulation.
– Ratio of Options to Cash Volumes: India’s options volumes are roughly four times the underlying cash trading volumes, compared to a global average of 5-15 times. This high ratio is a concern.
– Zero-Day Expiry Options: There are reservations about introducing zero-day expiry options contracts, as they are seen as purely speculative.
– Lot Sizes of Options Contracts: Increasing lot sizes may prevent very small investors from entering the market.
4. Market Data and Trends:
– Global and Indian Trading Statistics: Of the 108 billion options contracts traded worldwide in 2023, 78% were on Indian exchanges. Retail investors account for 35% of derivative trading in India.
– Retail Investor Activity: In April, 78% of trades on the National Stock Exchange were by investors trading less than 1 million rupees ($11,969).
5. Public Consultation and Implementation:
– Discussion Stage: The proposed changes are currently in the discussion phase and will be open for public consultation before being implemented.
6. Legal and Foreign Participation:
– Legal Disputes: U.S.-based firms Jane Street and Millennium are involved in a legal dispute over an India options strategy, with Jane Street claiming significant revenue from the strategy in 2023.
7. Official Comments:
– Pending Responses: Emails sent to SEBI and India’s finance ministry seeking comments have not yet been answered.
8. Expert Opinions:
– Will Acworth, FIA: The primary concern for the government and SEBI is investor protection, as buying options without understanding them is akin to gambling.
Stay informed with our financial updates, stocks, bonds, commodities. Get global & political insights. Follow us & enable notifications for the latest updates.